Dine In or Carry Out
Shisler’s Amish Sub…...6.99
Our very own creation of Trail bologna, Lebanon bologna and Streb’s hickory-smoked ham topped with Holmes County Swiss and Colby cheeses and honey mustard.
Italian Sub (Hot or Cold)......6.99
Genoa salami, pepperoni, capocolla ham, Provolone Cheese, mild pepper rings, tomato, lettuce, oil and vinegar.
Toasty Roast Beef Ciabatta…...6.99
Roast beef, pepper jack cheese, mild pepper rings, lettuce, tomato and garlic spread on a toasted ciabatta roll.
Corned beef, Holmes County Swiss Cheese, sauerkraut, Thousand Island Dressing on deli rye bread. (Served Warm)
Hot pastrami, melted Holmes County Swiss, coleslaw and deli mustard on rye bread. Also available with turkey pastrami. (Served Warm).
Buffalo Chicken Sub…...6.99
Buffalo chicken bread, spicy homemade buffalo sauce, Danish blue cheese, mayo, lettuce and tomato.
All-meat bologna, deluxe ham, Genoa salami, American cheese, yellow mustard, lettuce and tomato
Smoked ham, mesquite smoked turkey, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo served on your choice of bread.
Traditional Ovengold Turkey Club…...6.99
Roasted turkey, smoked bacon, Colby cheese, mayo, lettuce & tomato on your choice of fresh bread.
Honey turkey, honey ham, Havarti, bacon, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard and mayo.
Rosemary Ham Sandwich…...6.99
Italian rosemary ham, mozzarella cheese, fire-roasted tomatoes, served on your choice of bread.
DELI SALAD SANDWICHES
Our legendary homemade chicken salad featuring Boar’s Head rotisserie chicken, pecans and dried cherries.
Freshly made in house.
Smoked Ham Sandwich…...5.99
Streb’s old-fashioned hickory-smoked ham, Holmes County Swiss cheese and honey mustard served on your choice of bread.
Trail Bologna Sandwich…...5.99
Genuine Troyer’s specially seasoned, all-beef Train bologna, Holmes County Swiss cheese and yellow mustard served on your choice of bread.
Lebanon Bologna Sandwich…...5.99
Penn Dutch style, smoked, all-beef Lebanon bologna, Holmes County Swiss Cheese and yellow mustard on your choice of bread.
All-meat bologna, American Cheese, yellow mustard on Italian white bread.
Thick sliced bologna, American cheese, yellow mustard.
Liverwurst, tomato, onion on deli rye bread.
Streb’s smoked bacon, lettuce, fresh tomatoes & mayo.
Italian Fresh Market…...5.99
Basil pesto, mozzarella cheese, fresh tomato and green leaf lettuce with balsamic oil & vinegar dressing on a toasted ciabatta roll.
Cheese Lover’s Sandwich…...5.99
Triple cheese combo with Danish Havarti, Colby cheese and Baby Swiss, cucumber slices, onions, lettuce and tomato.
Irish Plowman’s Sandwich…...4.99
Medium sharp cheddar cheese and mango chutney served on choice of bread.
Choose from American, Holmes County Swiss, Havarti or hot pepper jack cheese.
Peanut Butter & Jelly…...3.00
Pairs perfectly with a glass of wine!
Holmes County Favorites…...9.99
Holmes County Swiss, Colby cheese, herb & garlic yogurt cheese, Trail bologna, crackers and honey mustard.
Sharp Vermont Cheddar, Chipotle Gouda, Baby Swiss Cheese, Hard Salami slices, crackers and mixed Greek Olives.
Around The World…...14.99
Jarlsberg, French double cream Brie, smoked Gouda, Italian dry salami, crackers and mixed Greek olives.
CREATE YOUR OWN
Sandwich, Sub, Ciabatta Roll, or Croissant…...ONLY 6.99
Create the combination that’s just right for you using Boar’s Head Deli Meats and award winning cheeses. All sandwiches can be made hot & toasty if your choose.
Shisler's Cheese House Meats
- Oven gold Turkey
- Mesquite Smoked Turkey
- Honey Maple Glazed Turkey
- Cajun Turkey
- Deluxe Ham
- Honey Maple Glazed Ham
- Roast Beef
- Corned Beef
- Rotisserie Chicken Breast
- Low Sodium Ham
- Garlic Bologna
- Holmes County Swiss
- Hot Pepper Jack
- Sharp Swiss
- Smoked Gouda
- Low Fat Lacey Swiss
- Premium or Extra Cheese- Add .75
- Mild Pepper Rings
- Black Olives
- Green Peppers
- Fire Roasted Tomatoes - add .50
- Yellow Mustard
- Deli-Style Mustard
- Dijon Mustard
- Honey Mustard
- Horseradish Sauce
- Pure Horseradish
- Oil/Red Wine Vinegar
- 1000 Island
- Ranch Dressing
- Miracle Whip
Your choice of white, wheat, spinach or sun-dried tomato wraps
* Turkey Wrap
Ovengold turkey, cream cheese spread, mild cheddar cheese, lettuce, cucumber slices and tomato.
* Roast Beef Wrap
Roast Beef, house herb cream cheese spread, Danish cream, Havarti, Horseradish sauce, Lettuce, onions, and tomato.
* Italian Wrap
Genoa salami, prosciutto, rosemary ham, pesto cream cheese spread, mozzarella cheese, olives, pepper rings, lettuce, and fire-roasted tomatoes with balsamic vinegar and oil dressing.
* Chicken BLT Wrap
Rotisserie chicken, crisp bacon, Monterey Jack Cheese, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing.
* Veggie Chicken Wrap
Rotisserie chicken, chopped assorted vegetables, low-fat Lacey Swiss and creamy balsamic dressing.
* Chipotle Chicken Wraps
Bold chipotle seasoned chicken, provolone cheese, hot sauce, ranch dressing with lettuce and tomatoes.
* Cajun Turkey Wrap
Cajun turkey, pepper jack cheese, black bean & corn salsa, lettuce and tomato.
* Veggie Wrap
Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, green peppers, pickles, onions, mild pepper rings, olives, cream cheese spread oil & vinegar.
* Greek Wrap
Our Veggie Wrap with Feta cheese and Greek Dressing.
Create a great start to your day! Try one of our fresh egg sandwiches with you choice of breakfast meat and cheese on a croissant, ciabatta or toast.
Virginia Ham | Bacon | Sausage | Roast Beef | Extra Meat or 2 Meats: Add 1.50
American | Holmes County Swiss | Sharp Cheddar | Hot Pepper Jack | Extra Cheese: Add .75
Ciabatta | Croissant
Toast Choices: White | Wheat | Rye | Pumpernickle
Copley Club Salad…...6.99
Fixed mixed lettuce, tomato, cucumber, carrots, onion, turkey, ham, cheddar cheese, crunchy sesame sticks and sunflower seeds.
Fresh mixed lettuce, tomato, cucumber, carrots, onions, ham, bacon, Swiss cheese and hard boiled egg.
Fresh mixed lettuce, tomato, cucumber, carrots, onion, salami, ham, provolone cheese, olives and peperoncini peppers.
Fixed mixed lettuce, tomato, cucumber, carrots and onions.
Smaller version of our garden salad.
Add Cheese…… .75
Feta, Blue Cheese or Provolone
Add Bacon…... 1.00
Add Egg…… .75
Add Chicken Salad…...3.00
Add Tuna Salad…...2.50
Add Egg Salad…...2.00
Salad Dressing Choices: Blush Wine Vinaigrette, Creamy Asiago, Caesar, French, Ranch, Italian, Thousand Island, Oil & Vinegar, Balsamic Vinegar and Oil, Fat-Free Sweet Vinegar & Olive Oil. Extra Dressing add .50
- Potato Salad…...1.25
- Macaroni Salad…...1.25
- Cole Slaw…...1.25
- Rotini Pasta Salad…...1.25
- Whole Deli Pickle…...1.00
- Mixed Greek Olives…...2.00
- Stuffed Cherry Peppers…...2 for 3.00
(Medium- hot cherry peppers stuffed with aged provolone and prosciutto)
- Chips Canton’s Own Golden Krisp Chips…...Sm.75/Med 1.39
- All-natural kettle chips (Asst. Flavors)......1.39
DAILY SOUP SELECTIONS
Side of Toasted ciabatta w/butter or seasoned garlic butter…...1.50
All of our sandwiches are made fresh to order- we will gladly modify any of our sandwiches to meet your satisfaction
Prices are subject to change
Monday through Friday, 9am-6pm Saturday